Smart Lighting vs. Automated Shades: Which Should You Install First?
Help in making a decision
David Rouse
10/1/20253 min read
Smart Lighting vs. Automated Shades: Which Should You Install First?
When starting your smart home journey, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. You know you want the convenience and energy savings of automation, but where do you begin? For most homeowners in New England, the decision comes down to two major categories: Smart Lighting (like Lutron,Crestron) or Automated Shades (like Lutron, Crestron and Hunter Douglas).
Both systems offer tremendous benefits, but they serve different foundational needs in your home. At DownEastShades, we specialize in both, and we’re here to help you decide which step makes the most sense to take first.
Understanding the Core Value
To make the best decision for your home, consider the primary role each system plays:
SystemPrimary BenefitKey FunctionCost to StartSmart LightingConvenience & SecurityControl of electric light sources (switches, dimmers, bulbs).Lower (Can start with a few switches/rooms)Automated ShadesComfort & Energy EfficiencyControl of natural light sources (windows).Higher (Typically done by the room or zone)
Why You Might Choose Smart Lighting First
Smart lighting is often the easiest and most affordable entry point into whole-home automation.
💡 1. Immediate, High-Impact Convenience
Swapping out a few dimmers for smart switches gives you instant control via voice, app, or schedule. Imagine: a single "Goodnight" button by your bed turns off every light in the house. The convenience is immediate and universally appreciated.
2. Enhanced Security and Presence Simulation
Smart lighting is a powerful security tool. You can set a "Vacation Mode" where lights turn on and off randomly at night, making it look like your Portland or Boston home is occupied, even when you're away.
3. Lower Cost of Entry
You don't have to automate every room at once. You can start with the most-used areas—the kitchen, living room, and master bedroom—and expand your system over time. This makes budgeting and installation a phased process.
Why You Might Choose Automated Shades First
Automated shades offer a profound impact on your home’s comfort, privacy, and energy use that lighting simply cannot match.
☀️ 1. Superior Energy Efficiency
The largest source of heat gain and loss in your home is through windows. Automated shades are your first line of defense. By setting shades to automatically lower during the hottest part of the summer day (or to close at dusk in winter), you dramatically reduce the strain on your HVAC system. This leads to significant, measurable savings on your utility bills.
2. Unmatched Privacy and Glare Control
Shades are essential for managing natural light. You can eliminate screen glare in a media room or secure instant privacy in a bathroom, all with the push of a button or a pre-set schedule. For large windows and sunrooms common across New England, automated shades are a necessity.
3. Protection for Interiors
UV rays can seriously damage hardwood floors, expensive furniture, and artwork. Scheduling your shades to partially close during peak sun hours protects your interior investments, helping your home look beautiful for longer.
The DownEastShades Recommendation
If your budget and initial comfort level allow for only one system, here is how we recommend you prioritize:
Your Priority is...Install This FirstBecause...Energy Savings & ComfortAutomated ShadesThey manage the most powerful element (the sun) and offer the greatest long-term utility savings.Security & Immediate ControlSmart LightingThe high-impact convenience and security features are easy to implement and expand quickly.Design AestheticsAutomated ShadesCustom fabrics, quiet motors, and wire-free solutions dramatically enhance the look and feel of a room instantly.
The Ultimate Goal: Seamless Integration
Ultimately, the best smart home uses both systems working together. Imagine a single button labeled "Movie Night" that simultaneously:
Dimmers the lights to 10%.
Lowers the blackout shades completely.
Turns on your TV or projector.
Whether you start with shades or lighting, both systems are designed to be integrated down the line. We can help you select a platform (like Lutron) that ensures all components speak the same language, future-proofing your investment.
Ready to Take the First Step?
Don't let the dilemma stop your smart home dreams. Whether you are ready for a full installation or just have more questions about Lutron products, contact DownEastShades today for a free, in-home consultation in the Greater Portland or Boston areas. Let us help you design the perfect smart solution for your needs.
Call Us at 781-502-5770 or Request a Consultation Now.